The loyalty app market in the United States is crowded. Dozens of platforms claim to be the best solution for small businesses, ranging from free tools to enterprise-grade systems that cost hundreds of dollars per month. For a small business owner with limited time and budget, cutting through the noise is a challenge.
This article compares four loyalty platforms relevant to the US market in 2026: Fedele, Fivestars (by SumUp), Stamp Me, and Belly (now Mobivity). The goal is not to declare a winner but to analyze features, pricing, system type, ease of use, and limitations so you can make an informed decision for your business.
What to look for in a loyalty app for the US market
Before diving into individual platforms, here are the criteria that matter for an American small business in 2026:
- Points-per-dollar-spent system — The fairest and most flexible model for any type of business
- No additional hardware — Your smartphone should be sufficient
- Free plan or trial — To test without financial risk before committing
- Barcode scanning — Fast, frictionless, works with any smartphone
- Simple setup — Configurable in minutes, not days
- Customer data and analytics — Understanding who comes back and how often
- No long-term contracts — Flexibility to cancel or change plans
The 4 best loyalty apps in the USA: detailed comparison
1. Fedele
Type: Native mobile app (iOS + Android) for points-based loyalty programs Target market: Small and medium businesses Languages: English, Italian
Fedele is a mobile app designed for small businesses that want a professional loyalty program without complexity. The system is entirely based on points per dollar spent: at each purchase, the merchant scans the customer's barcode from their own smartphone, enters the amount, and points are calculated automatically.
Key features:
- Points per dollar spent with customizable ratio
- Unlimited custom rewards
- Barcode scanning (for awarding points and redeeming rewards)
- Integrated map for business visibility
- Configurable welcome bonus for new members
- Merchant dashboard with customer statistics
- No additional hardware required
Pricing:
- Free plan: EUR 0/month, up to 5 customers, all core features
- Premium plan: EUR 49.99/month (billed annually at EUR 599.99) or EUR 59.99/month (monthly billing), unlimited customers, priority email support
Strengths:
- Permanent free plan to start without risk
- No hardware to purchase: your smartphone is enough
- Flexible points system suitable for any industry
- Map visibility for acquiring new customers
- Setup in under 10 minutes
- No contracts or long-term commitments
Limitations:
- Free plan limited to 5 customers (designed for initial testing)
- No direct POS integration (designed to work independently)
- Pricing in EUR (competitive when converted to USD)
2. Fivestars (by SumUp)
Type: Digital loyalty and marketing platform with POS integration Target market: US small and medium businesses (restaurants, retail, services) Languages: English
Fivestars is one of the most established loyalty platforms in the US market. Originally an independent company, it was acquired by SumUp and now operates as part of the SumUp ecosystem. The platform combines loyalty with automated marketing features and POS integration.
Key features:
- Points and rewards system
- Automated marketing campaigns (birthday rewards, win-back campaigns)
- Customer segmentation and analytics
- POS integration (primarily with SumUp terminals)
- Touchscreen check-in at the register
Pricing:
- No publicly listed free plan
- Pricing typically starts at $299/month or higher depending on the package and POS bundle
- Often requires a SumUp POS terminal purchase or rental
- Custom pricing for multi-location businesses
Strengths:
- Deep POS integration for seamless checkout experience
- Automated marketing features reduce manual work
- Established brand with large US merchant network
- Customer segmentation and targeted campaigns
- Rating between 3.9-4.1 on app stores
Limitations:
- Significantly more expensive than most alternatives
- Requires POS hardware or SumUp terminal
- Locked into the SumUp ecosystem after acquisition
- No free plan to test before committing
- Contract terms can be inflexible
- Overkill for very small businesses that need a simple solution
3. Stamp Me
Type: Mobile app for digital stamp/visit-based loyalty programs Target market: Small businesses globally (strong in Australia, UK, USA) Languages: English
Stamp Me is an Australian platform that digitizes the classic stamp card concept. Customers earn digital "stamps" with each visit or purchase, and after a predefined number of stamps, they receive a reward. The platform has a 4.9-star rating on the App Store and a polished user experience.
Key features:
- Digital stamps (visit-based system)
- Merchant dashboard
- Push notifications and SMS
- StampPod (NFC validation device)
- Birthday Club campaigns and automations
- Email integration
Pricing:
- Lite plan: approximately $39/month — Unlimited users, 1 location, basic validation methods
- Medium plan: approximately $59/month — Automations, unlimited push notifications, advanced analytics
- Large plan: approximately $119/month — Multi-location, API access, white-label options
Strengths:
- Excellent app store rating (4.9 stars)
- Clean and intuitive user interface
- Advanced features in higher plans (automations, push notifications)
- Good documentation and case studies
- Works well in English-speaking markets
Limitations:
- Stamp/visit-based system, not points per dollar spent: a customer who spends $50 gets the same stamp as one who spends $5
- No free plan: even the basic plan requires $39/month
- Some plans require dedicated hardware (StampPod NFC device)
- Australian company with primary support in Australian business hours
- Stamp system is inherently less fair than a points-per-dollar model
4. Belly (now Mobivity)
Type: Digital loyalty platform with tablet-based check-in Target market: US small businesses (restaurants, retail, fitness) Languages: English
Belly was one of the early digital loyalty platforms in the US. It has since been rebranded and absorbed into Mobivity, a mobile marketing company. The platform uses tablet-based check-in and integrates with Apple Wallet for digital loyalty cards.
Key features:
- Tablet-based check-in at the register
- Integration with Apple Wallet
- Email marketing and campaign tools
- Customer analytics dashboard
- Social media integration
- Customizable reward tiers
Pricing:
- Pricing is not transparently listed and requires contacting sales
- Historical pricing ranged from $99 to $199/month depending on features
- Tablet hardware typically required
Strengths:
- Apple Wallet integration for convenience
- Rating approximately 4.5 on app stores
- Established presence in the US market
- Social media sharing features to boost word of mouth
Limitations:
- Confusing brand transition from Belly to Mobivity creates uncertainty
- Requires tablet hardware at the register
- Opaque pricing requires a sales conversation
- Interface can feel outdated compared to newer alternatives
- Uncertain product roadmap following the Mobivity transition
- Not as actively developed as competing platforms
Head-to-head comparison: summary table
| Feature | Fedele | Fivestars (SumUp) | Stamp Me | Belly (Mobivity) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Type | Points-based loyalty app | Loyalty + marketing + POS | Stamp-based loyalty app | Tablet-based loyalty |
| Points system | Yes (per dollar spent) | Yes | No (stamps/visits) | Tier-based |
| Custom rewards | Unlimited | Yes | Limited to stamp system | Customizable tiers |
| Free plan | Yes (5 customers) | No | No | No |
| Monthly price | From EUR 0 | From ~$299 | From ~$39 | Contact sales (~$99-199) |
| Hardware required | None (smartphone) | SumUp POS terminal | Optional (StampPod NFC) | Tablet required |
| Barcode scanning | Yes | No (POS-based) | QR code | Tablet check-in |
| Map visibility | Yes | Limited | No | No |
| POS integration | No (independent) | Yes (SumUp) | No | Limited |
| Setup time | Under 10 minutes | Requires onboarding | 15-30 minutes | Requires onboarding |
| Contracts | None | Often required | Monthly | Often required |
Which loyalty app should you choose for your US business?
The choice depends on your specific needs, budget, and business type:
Choose Fedele if:
- You want a dedicated, professional, and flexible loyalty program
- You prefer a points-per-dollar-spent system
- You want to start free and pay only when you are ready to scale
- You do not want to purchase additional hardware
- You need a solution that works in under 10 minutes
- Budget is a priority and you want the lowest entry cost
Choose Fivestars if:
- You already use SumUp for payment processing
- You have the budget for a premium solution ($299+/month)
- You want deep POS integration and automated marketing
- You need advanced customer segmentation features
Choose Stamp Me if:
- You prefer a stamp/visit-based system rather than points per dollar
- You are willing to pay $39+/month from day one
- You need push notification and automation features
- A polished mobile experience is your top priority
Choose Belly/Mobivity if:
- You want Apple Wallet integration
- You are comfortable with tablet-based check-in
- You want social media integration features
- You are willing to navigate opaque pricing and sales conversations
Our analysis
For US small businesses in 2026, the loyalty app market divides into two categories: expensive, hardware-dependent solutions and lightweight, mobile-first alternatives.
Fivestars offers a comprehensive feature set, but its price tag of $299 or more per month puts it out of reach for many small businesses. The SumUp acquisition also means you are increasingly locked into a specific payment ecosystem.
Stamp Me delivers a polished experience, but the stamp-based system is inherently less fair than points per dollar: it does not differentiate between a $5 purchase and a $50 one. The lack of a free plan means financial commitment from day one.
Belly's transition to Mobivity introduces uncertainty. The platform's future direction is unclear, and the requirement for tablet hardware adds cost and complexity.
Fedele takes a different approach: a points-per-dollar system that is fair and flexible, a free plan that lets you test with real customers at zero cost, and a smartphone-only setup that requires no hardware purchases or POS integration. While pricing is in EUR, the Premium plan at EUR 49.99/month (approximately $54/month at current exchange rates) is significantly more affordable than US-based alternatives that charge $100-$300 per month for comparable or even fewer features. For American small businesses looking for value without compromise, the math speaks clearly.
See pricing and get started for free
FAQ
What is the best loyalty app for small businesses in the USA?
For small businesses looking for a no-hardware, low-cost option, Fedele offers the best value: a free plan, a points-per-dollar system, and smartphone-only setup with no POS integration required. Fivestars offers more features but starts at $299/month, which is out of reach for most independent businesses.
Are there free loyalty apps for US small businesses?
Yes. Fedele offers a permanent free plan (up to 5 customers) with no credit card required. Most other US-focused platforms like Fivestars and Belly do not offer a free tier — they require paid subscriptions from day one.
Do loyalty apps require special hardware?
It depends on the platform. Fivestars and Belly require a tablet for customer check-in. Fedele works entirely from your existing smartphone — no additional hardware, no POS integration, no extra cost.
How much do loyalty apps cost in the USA?
Prices range from free (Fedele's free plan) to $299+/month (Fivestars). Stamp Me charges per location. Fedele's Pro plan costs €49.99/month (approximately $54/month), making it significantly more affordable than US-based alternatives with comparable features.
Can a loyalty app work for any type of US small business?
Yes. Coffee shops, restaurants, retail stores, salons, gyms, and pharmacies all benefit from loyalty programs. The key is choosing a system that matches your average ticket size and visit frequency — a points-per-dollar model works for most business types.
Related articles
Ready to build customer loyalty?
Create your Fedele loyalty program in minutes — no hardware, no code.
Get Started